Saturday, September 18, 2010

The "Lost" Christianity of Asia

It's been a bit of a busy time for me lately so I've not had a lot of opportunity to write here. I've also been taking whatever time I get to catch up on some reading. One book I found really fascinating was Philip Jenkins' The Lost History of Christianity: The Thousand Year Golden Age of the Church in the Middle East and Africa - and How It Died. Despite its title, the book focuses mainly on Middle Eastern Syriac Christianity and its spread through Asia into China, Mongolia, India and even Tibet. A thousand years ago, Christianity was a thoroughly 'global' religion stretching across three continents from the Pacific to the Atlantic, with Christian states flourishing up the Nile valley in the heart of modern Sudan and also up into Ethiopia. A thousand years ago Russia and much of northern Europe were only just embracing Christianity and yet Silk Road cities like Samarkand, Bukhara, Kashgar, even Herat in Afghanistan had centuries old flourishing Christian communities, complete with monasteries, schools and colleges, where theology, philosophy and also biblical studies had been taught for generations. As Jenkins points out, nowadays Christianity is regarded as a European religion, but that Euro-centrism is a fairly recent development, only being achieved by the eve of the Renaissance. Even 800 years ago the notion that Europe, let alone Western Europe, was a key centre of Christianity would have been risible to Christians in the East and the South. Most Asian and African Christians regarded European Christianity in both its Latin and Byzantine forms as thoroughly heretical, and the Latins of the West as barely above barbarism.

Sadly, most of this history is unknown. For those with an interest in (Christian) history, like myself, there would be occasional glimpses of this past but trying to get more details was often frustrating. And so I'll provide a quick summary before giving further reflections. The old Asian Christianity was derived from Syriac Christianity of the Middle East. Syriac is a form of Aramaic, which was the lingua franca of the Middle East until the coming of Islam and Arabic in the 7th century CE (the Arabic alphabet is derived from Syriac script). The Syriac heartland embraced Iraq, south-eastern Turkey, Syria, Lebanon and Israel/Palestine/Jordan. In the first centuries it was divided between the two great empires of Rome and Persia (Parthian and then Sassanian). The border between these two empires regularly shifted backwards and forwards across what's now western Syria and northern Iraq but the Syriac culture flourished on both sides. Christianity spread from its Middle Eastern heartland into both the Roman and Persian empires and then beyond. While in Rome, Christianity became Greek, Egyptian and Latin as well as Syriac, in Persia it remained largely Syriac, retaining Syriac as its liturgical language and using the Peshitta Syriac translations of scripture as their Bible.

As it was persecuted and an illicit religion in the Roman state, Christianity was initially well received in Persia, perhaps on the principle of the enemy of my enemy is my friend. But at the same time Persia itself was a religiously plural society. There were many old established Jewish communities, especially in what's now Iraq, together with Mandaeans and Gnostic sects. Buddhism was still an important presence, especially in the east in Afghanistan. The Persian religion, Zoroastrianism would itself be shaped into a state church by the Sassanian state but it also had its dissident sects such as the Mazdakites. And from the 3rd century Manicheism also joined the religious mix and was a serious rival to Christianity in the 4th and 5th centuries. Indeed one could say that the Persian state was much more pluralist religiously than Rome whose paganisms functioned mostly as local cults with only the Imperial cult of Rome and Emperor providing any broadly based religious superstructure. Following Constantine, and the growing Christianisation of the Roman state through the 4th century, Persian attitudes to Christianity changed and so while persecution ended in the Roman state (and most of those persecutions took place in the East in the Syriac and Greek and Egyptian territories forcing many Christians to flee east into Persia) the Persian state regarded Christianity with suspicion and hostility and carried out waves of severe persecutions of Christians in the 4th and 5th centuries.

In the 5th century, Christianity in the Roman East was torn apart by a series of Christological controversies about how the divinity and the humanity of Christ functioned together in the person of Jesus. The first such controversy centred around the person of Nestorius, a Christian theologian from Syria who became Archbishop of Constantinople in 428 CE. He tried to resolve a Christological dispute in Constantinople but only succeeded in alienating both against him. Worse he incurred the enmity of the Egyptian Church leadership and at the Council of Ephesus in 431 his views were condemned as heretical and Nestorius, deposed, retired to a monastery. Many of his supporters in Syria and elsewhere, however, moved east into Persia, including the scholars of the Christian university at Edessa (modern Urfa, in Turkey) which was closed by the Roman state because of its associations with heresy. This influx of 'Nestorians' and the associated disputations spurred Christians in Persia to declare their Church separate from the Church in the Roman Empire (thus making themselves less suspect in the eyes of the Persian state too). Thus was born the Church of the East.

The Church of the East initially comprised the Church of the Persian state, which ruled Afghanistan and southern Central Asia as well as modern Iraq, along with Christian communities in Arabia, in Bahrain, Oman and Yemen, and across into India where Christianity had been established, largely in the south, since the first century. A Catholicos or universal Patriarch was established in Seleucia-Ctesiphon, the Sassanian capital, and would remain there until the Islamic period when it relocated to Baghdad under the Abbasid Caliphate. By 800, the Catholicos of the Church of the East presided over 19 metropolitanates/archdioceses and 85 bishops from Persia into India, Central Asia, Tibet, Xinjiang and China. These metropolitanates included Beijing and Xian in China, Patna in India, Tangut in Tibet, Khotan and Kashgar in Xinjiang, Samarkand, Bukhara and Merv in Central Asia and Herat in (modern) Afghanistan. As Jenkins observes, medieval England in later centuries only had two metropolitanates, Canterbury and York. Samarkand and Bukhara and Kashgar were thriving centres of Christianity before there was even a church establishment at Canterbury.

Meanwhile back in Rome, the deposition of Nestorius did not mark the end of Christological disputes. These continued in even greater ferocity culminating in the Council of Chalcedon in 451 which condemned Monophysite Christology. Ironically it was the Egyptian Church that now fell foul and along with it the Armenian and Ethiopian and Nubian churches too. By this time Monophysite theology had taken root in Syria as well generating a further schism by which the Syrian Orthodox or Jacobite Church (not to be confused with the Byzantine rite, and Chalcedonian, Antiochian Orthodox Church also based in Syria) joined with its Oriental Orthodox sister churches in Egypt, Armenia etc as separate from the Roman-Byzantine Great Church of the rest of the Roman Empire and the West. For the next two centuries the Eastern Roman Empire was torn apart by the Monophysite controversy such that when the Arab armies of Islam came riding into Syria and Egypt they were welcomed by the local Christians as liberators from Byzantine oppression.

Byzantine persecution meant that many Monophysite Syrian Orthodox would also flee east into Persia and settle in what is now Iraq. Consequently, there were now two Syriac churches in Persia, the greater and long established Church of the East and the lesser Syrian Orthodox Church. I say greater and lesser because the Church of the East spread throughout Persia and Asia whereas the Syrian Orthodox Church remained mostly in the Middle East and only many centuries later would develop a connection with Indian Christians in the 17th/18th centuries.

It's instructive to reflect in these days of "clash of civilisation" rhetoric that, while the Arab/Muslim invasions were a calamity for Eastern Roman/Byzantine Empire and an utter disaster for the Persian Empire, the local Christians (and Jews and Samaritans) of Egypt and Syria for the most part welcomed Muslim rule as the lifting of an oppressive and heretical yoke. The Church of the East, never having been an official state sponsored religion, were none too concerned by the new Islamic rule, either. In many respects it meant an improvement in conditions because Muslims and Christians had much more in common than Christians and Zoroastrians. As I said earlier the Persian state was much more of a religiously plural society than the old Roman state had been and Islam initially was yet another addition to the religious mix. There were no forced conversions of Christians and for many centuries Christianity continued to flourish in Syria and Egypt while the Church of the East continued its missionary work in central Asia and China and India.

What was also key for those early Christian Muslim relations too was Christian scholarship and education. I've already mentioned the Christian university at Edessa. When it was closed by the Roman state it relocated itself to Nisibis in Persia (now Nusaybin in southeastern Turkey). As well as teaching theology and philosophy it also taught medicine, and I was surprised to discover from Jenkins that Christians were prized in both the Persian and later Islamic Empires for their medical skills. It's become a truism that it was the Arab/Islamic state that preserved much of the knowledge of the classical world and transmitted it to the medieval West. What I hadn't known was that it was Syriac Christians who translated the Greek texts into Arabic (and Syriac too) - even the Iliad was translated into Arabic by a Syriac Christian, Thawafil Ibn Tuma. Indeed the period up until the 12th centuries saw a flowering of Christian scholarship not only in the Islamic world but in the other Christian states of the region, Armenia, Georgia, Nubia and Ethiopia as well as in the Christian centres along the Silk Road. One of these, Merv (Mary in modern Turkmenistan), was for a period in the 12th century the largest city in the world. The Church of the East had been established here for many centuries in a multi-faith community of Muslims, Jews, Zoroastrians and at different times, Buddhists and Manichees. It was one of the great centres of Christianity in the world. From 500 CE, the Christian school at Merv had been translating Greek and Syriac texts into a variety of central and eastern Asian languages (Sogdian, Bactrian, Turkic, Uighur etc). During my PhD, I met one of the scions of that school, Isho'dad of Merv who lived in the 9th century and became bishop of Haditha in Iraq in 850 CE. Isho'dad was a scripture scholar and wrote commentaries on both the Old and New Testaments. I worked with his Old Testament commentary, which was the only Syriac commentary on Judges I could find. I should point out that I had resolved to include as many Syriac authors I could find and not restrict myself to the Greek and Latin Fathers only. There wasn't that much available. I worked with Ephrem Syrus, the great 4th century Syriac theologian, mystic, monk and poet who is counted as a Father of the Church by all the Oriental and Eastern Orthodox plus Roman Catholic and other Western Catholic and Protestant churches. As well as Ephrem, I drew on texts by Isho bar Nun, Aphrahat and some commentary compendiums of Syriac sources, mostly on Genesis. Isho'dad was crucial for my thesis but the version I had was a Syriac text with a French parallel translation. I don't think any of his work is available in English. I can't read Syriac (although I'd like to) but I could work with the French translation and we had a Syriac specialist in the department so if I wanted to doublecheck what was the Syriac that the French was translating (to verify the validity of the translation) I could consult with him. What particularly fascinated me about the Syriac texts was their familiarity with Jewish traditions and readings of the biblical stories. And it, must not be forgotten that the ancient Iraq that was the centre of the Syriac Christianity was also at the same time the world centre for Judaism, with thriving centres of rabbinic learning and, of course the place where the Babylonian Talmud was redacted at roughly the same time the Church of the East had become established as an independent entity. The evidence of the Syriac texts showed that Christians and Jews engaged with each other and that Christians were not averse to adopting Jewish readings of their shared scriptures (I would later find that some Muslim Qur'anic scholars likewise were familiar with both Jewish and Christian exegesis and would draw on it when commenting on the Qur'an). And of course the Silk Road cities like Merv, Samarkand and Bukhara were home to thriving Jewish communities too. Isho'dad would have been familiar with Jews long before he moved to Mesopotamia. If you want to find out more about Syriac scholarship there's an overview of Christian Syriac literature and scholarship here.

What was equally fascinating about Jenkins' book was his account of ancient Chinese Christianity. We don't know when Christianity made it to China (or Judaism either which like Christianity, Buddhism, Manicheeism and Islam came along the Silk Road). What I didn't know was that it was Christian monks who smuggled silkworms out of China in 550 CE, bringing them to Constantinople (which presumably indicates they were Orthodox monks not monks of the Church of the East). But the real flourishing of Chinese Christianity in the first millennium came during the Tang dynasty. According to Jenkins a formal mission was established in the Chinese capital in 635 CE. They were welcomed by the Emperor who was very open to new faiths. He also allowed the entry of Buddhism into China. Christianity was known as Jiangjiao, the luminous teaching, and it spread establishing monasteries throughout China. At the end of the 8th century the Church was led by a Bishop Adam and Jenkins tells an amazing story of interfaith co-operation by this bishop. A Buddhist missionary, Prajna, arrived in China with a collection of Sanskrit texts but he was unable to translate them into Chinese. Adam and his monks had already translated some of the East Syriac Bible into Chinese and so Adam and his monks assisted these Buddhist monks to translate these sutras into Chinese. Interestingly these texts were taken to Japan and became the founding texts of two major Buddhist schools, Shingon and Tendai, from which derived all the great Japanese Buddhist movements including Zen and Pure Land. Also interesting is that the Church of the East in parts of China and India used as its symbol the cross joined with the lotus.

Christianity, along with Buddhism and Zoroastrianism, was expelled from China in the mid-9th century. The monasteries were closed and monks either sent out out of the country or forced back to lay life. The Church of the East came back to China in the Mongol period two centuries later and flourished for another 3 centuries. In 1275, two Christian monks from China set out on a pilgrimage to the Holy Land. They went along the Silk Road and stayed at Christian monasteries along the way, when they arrived in Mesopotamia they decided to travel around what for them was the "heart of the Christian world". So they visited churches in Baghdad before travelling on to Mosul and Arbela and Nisibis and Mardin (in modern Turkey). All the way they visited shrines and monasteries and religious houses, meeting with monks and priests and bishops. The Patriarch-Catholicos died and one of the two monks, Markos (who was probably a Uighur), was elected to the office and took the name Yaballaha (III) (1281-1317). The Church then comprised 30 provinces and 250 bishoprics across Asia. The other monk, Bar Sauma, who was probably an Onngud Turk from near Beijing, was sent to Europe on a diplomatic mission by the Mongol IlKhan. Now a bishop, Bar Sauma travelled to Rome and western Europe, causing quite a sensation. Nevertheless he was well received and even gave communion to the king of England. He also received communion from Pope Nicholas IV on Palm Sunday 1288 and was able to celebrate the Eucharist with Syriac rites in Rome too. You can read an account of his travels translated from Syriac here.

As Jenkins observes, however, Bar Sauma's journey took place on the eve of the collapse of the Church of the East. I think one of the strengths of the Church of the East (and the Coptic Church in Egypt plus the Syrian Orthodox in Syro-Mesopotamia) was that they had never been official state religions. The Coptic and Syrian Churches had in fact suffered regular bouts of persecution from the Roman-Byzantine state, such that in Egypt especially Christianity had become the life and soul of the people. The Church of the East had had its own share of persecution but more importantly had always functioned in a religiously plural world. However reading between the lines, it's clear that a key conversion strategy for any religion worth its salt was to secure the allegiance of a royal court. Jews did it with the Khazars, Manichees did it with the Uighurs, Christians did it, most famously with Rome, but also with Armenia, Nubia, Georgia, Ethiopia and much earlier, with Osrohene in Mesopotamia, Buddhists did in India and Afghanistan and Central Asia, and Muslims, too, did it Central Asia and amongst the Turkish and Mongol invaders of the Middle East. The Church of the East tried too, especially with the Mongols both in Central Asia and China but without success. Not long after Bar Sauma's journey to Europe, however, the Central Asian Mongol IlKhans embraced Islam and the Church of the East not only fell out of favor but had to face a new hostility that it had not experienced for a very long time.

As I said earlier, the Arab invasions of the Middle East and Persia, were not seen by most Christians or Jews there as a calamity but a welcome event. The Zoroastrian 'Church' in Persia being a state institution, understandably did not share those sentiments but even so the Arab Muslims did not initially force mass conversions but accorded Zoroastrianism the status of peoples of the book, dhimmis, along with Christians and Jews and others. Indeed many Arabs, didn't want to convert the subject populations at all because they wanted to retain a privileged status that might be imperiled if Islam became something for everybody. So, ironically, for Syriac and Egyptian Christianity (and even the Byzantine Orthodoxy of Palestine) the first centuries of Arab Muslim rule saw a flourishing of the local Christian cultures.

Nevertheless, it didn't take long for Islam to embrace a universalist role to be a religion for all rather than an exclusively Arab faith. And obviously many people converted; many out of genuine conviction, others because it represented a career move or lift in status, or at least, the obverse, to be free of the various legal and financial restrictions that went with having dhimmi status. Periodically too zealous Muslim rulers tried to forcibly convert the dhimmi populations. Furthermore the Islamic Empire had a number of Christian states as neighbours, in particular the Roman-Byzantine Empire whose heartland was still modern day Turkey and its capital, Constantinople. So international politics could also impact on religious matters. Still the Egyptian and Syriac Christians regarded the Byzantine Church as heretical and the Roman state as a former persecutor and so didn't look to Constantinople as an ally at all.

In fact it was the decline of both the Arab and Roman states that set the framework for the eclipse of Asian and African Christianity. In both cases the centre lost the ability to enforce more than a nominal authority across the realm. The struggle to retain central authority was exacerbated by the intervention of outside forces i.e. invasion. Probably the most famous of these are the Crusades but the most serious were those from Central Asia, the Turks and then the Mongols and finally Timur or Tamerlane who in the 14th century combined anti-Christian jihad with an overarching policy of brutal conquest and slaughter of Muslims and dhimmis alike.

The first Crusade was supposed to have provided assistance to the Roman Emperor in Constantinople in resisting the Muslim Seljuq Turks who were invading the Anatolian heartland of the Empire. Instead, and unfortunately, they went on to conquer the Levantine coast and finally Jerusalem. Even though the Latin Christians were regarded as heretical barbarians by Middle Eastern Christians, the fact of not one but three invasions or Crusades by Christians from the West, made Christianity a thoroughly suspect religion in the Islamic world (analogously, think of German or Italian or Japanese communities in Australia or the US during WW2 or communists and other leftists during the Cold War in the same countries). The Crusaders finally attacked and sacked Constantinople itself in 1204 and attempted to establish a Latin Empire for themselves. So far from assisting the Roman state to retake its territories in Anatolia, the Crusades helped to further undermine Constantinople and enable the consolidation of Turkish rule in Anatolia, which was accompanied by massacres and Islamisation. The Byzantine Christian city of Ephesus, at which was held the Council back in 431 that condemned Nestorius impelling the independence of the Church of the East, was "obliterated" (Jenkins) by the Turks in 1304, bringing to an end over a thousand years of Christianity there and possibly 2000 years of Greek culture.

Even worse though were the Mongol invasions of the Middle East in the 13th century. Baghdad itself was destroyed by the Mongols under Hulagu. The Mongol state was a pagan and multi-faith entity, including Christians and Muslims. Ironically some Mongol generals were Christians belonging to the Church of the East. So at first Mongol suzerainty worked out well for the Church of the East as evidenced by Bar Sauma's diplomatic mission to the West. However in 1290 the Mongol Khans converted to Islam, which resulted in attacks on Christians in Mesopotamia and elsewhere. Christians were a safe target for Muslims seeking vengeance for the sufferings they had endured under the Mongols. Patriarch Yaballaha III died at the hands of a mob.

The death blow came at the hands of Timur or Tamerlane in the 14th century. His conquests throughout Central Asia, Persia, Mesopotamia and Anatolia targeted Christians (in part to make up for his massacres of Muslim populations that resisted him too). Under the Timur, the Silk Road finally was closed and the long-flourishing centres of Christianity perished. Of the rich multi-faith world that was Central Asia only the Jews would remain as a non-Muslim minority. At the same time the Mongol dynasty in China came to an end, replaced by the Ming dynasty. Christianity went into eclipse and with the loss of contact with the Middle Eastern centre eventually disappeared. So, too, did the Manichees who appear to have morphed into a variety of Buddhist sects. As in Central Asia, only the Jews survived, the last functioning community in Kaifeng continuing into the 19th century. Tamerlane's armies rode through modern day Iraq and Jenkins gives harrowing details of how Christians were hunted down and massacred. At the same time in Egypt the local Muslim authorities unleashed a persecution of Christians reducing them to the minority (roughly 10%) that they remain today. Jenkins notes a class dynamic too, it was richer and urban Christians in Egypt who tended to convert while the poor and those in rural communities clung to their faith. Egypt also attacked and conquered the Christian Nubian kingdoms to the south and imposed a process of forced Islamisation there too. Even so a Christian statelet hung on until the late 15th century, indigenous Sudanese Christianity finally dying out by the time the Jews were expelled from Spain.

Jenkins points out that the attack on minorities as not simply a Middle Eastern phenomenon. In Europe the 13th and 14th centuries saw attacks on Jews with Jews being expelled from England and France and pogroms and massacres in the Rhineland. And in the early 13th century there was the Albigensian Crusade that wiped out the Cathars of Provence. He also highlights environmental factors; the world had entered a phase of global cooling which resulted in increased desertification, failing harvests, famine and disease. The 14th century was also the time of the Black Death which struck in the Middle East and Asia as well as in Europe.

Nevertheless, while Christianity disappeared from much of Asia and the Sudan, it hung on in the Middle East (the Church of the East also survived unscathed in India but would suffer its own agonies with the coming of the Europeans in the 16th century). A century ago, approximately 11% of the Middle East was Christian, now it is approximately 3% (although in Egypt, Christians are still approximately 10% of the population). In Palestine, Christians were once 15% of the Arab population now they are only 1%. In Iraq, the Christian population has shrunk from 6% to 1%. The 20th century has been another time of crisis for Middle Eastern Christianity in which there have been three catastrophes.

The first was the great genocide during the First World War. Everyone knows of it as the Armenian genocide in which at least a million Armenians were exterminated by the Ottoman state from 1915. Less well known is the Assyrian genocide of Syriac Christians conducted at the same time by the Ottoman state. The uplands of Mesopotamia and northern Syria in modern day Turkey and Kurdistan were where the Syriac/Assyrian/Suroye Christians had settled following the depredations of the 14th century. These uplands overlapped with and adjoined the Armenian territories of the Ottoman Empire. So all were targeted for elimination, and just about all were (small pockets of the Syrian Orthodox Church survive in the regions of Turkey north of Syria but the Assyrian and Armenian populations of the lands further east in Turkey no longer exist). Following WW1 there were further pogroms against the Assyrians in Iraq and in the 1930s the Patriarch of the Assyrian Church (the old Catholicos of the Church of the East) fled to the US and to this day the Assyrian Patriarchate is based in Chicago (however a schism in the Church in Iraq led to the formation of the Ancient Church of the East with a Patriarch resident in Iraq).

In the 20th century, Middle Eastern Christians were in the forefront of secular Arab nationalism, and pan-Arabism and socialism. Christians helped found the Ba'ath party in Syria (ba'ath means resurrrection or renaissance in Arabic). In Palestine, Christians were in the forefront of the Palestinian resistance to Zionism. Indeed, one could say that Zionism and the establishment of the Zionist state in Israel was a second catastrophe for Middle Eastern Christians, especially Palestinian Christians but also Lebanese too. In the latter part of the 20th century, the Palestinian struggle shifted from a secular struggle to a religiously polarised one between Islam and Judaism/the West. Local Christians were caught in the middle and their situation wasn't helped by the Christian Zionism of many Evangelicals and Pentecostals in the US (somewhat reminiscent of the plight of Middle Eastern Christians following the Crusades). These US forms of Christianity are real Johnny come latelies compared to the Palestinian Christians who can trace their history back to the first century CE. And like the Crusaders, before them these US Christians, are not only bizarre but heretical to boot, in the eyes of the Palestinian Church(es). So the Israel-Palestinian conflict has resulted in an ongoing and accelerated Christian Palestinian emigration.

The last catastrophe was the US invasion of Iraq. Saddam might have been a dictator but his was a secular regime in which religious minorities (with the exception of the Jews) could live relatively safely and prosper. (Saddam's hometown, Tikrit, used to be an important centre for the Syrian Orthodox Church many centuries ago). The US invasion put an end to that and once more like the Crusades of old associated Christianity with the oppressive outsider. The Christian and Mandaean populations of Iraq have been caught in the crossfire and associated with the infidel invaders generating a large scale emigration. Ancient communities that had survived all manner of catastrophes, even genocide, are disappearing rapidly. Many have fled to neighbouring Syria and Syria remains a richly multi-faith society. It has many varieties of Islam and Christianity, as well as other minority faiths, including a very small Jewish community.

I have long been fascinated by and drawn to the Christianity of the East. Jenkins' book gives an excellent overview of a history that is largely hidden and unknown. While I, like many, can find the glories of Christian Constantinople (and Christian Alexandria too for that matter) quite intoxicating, I think I would love to tread that old Silk Road and visit that rich multi-faith world in which Christianity was a key component but not a controlling one. To visit the Christian academies of Nisibis and Baghdad and Samarkand and Merv and Tabriz and Herat and Kashgar and talk scripture with the scholars there. To walk in a world where Christian and Buddhist and Manichee monasteries often sat side by side, where Christian monks helped Buddhist monks translate their scriptures. Imagine if that world had survived and continued to flourish!

I think that world provides a model for ours.

Friday, September 10, 2010

Jonah and the Anguish of History

Here in Australia, the dramas of government and the election seem to have reached a resolution in a Labor minority government with the support of the Greens and several Independents. We're entering a new phase of federal politics about which I'm cautiously optimistic. It's certainly the best result given what was on offer at the election last month. And we have been spared the ordeal of an Abbott Coalition government which would represent a return to Howardism at its worst. And I actually think the current arrangement will result in fairly progressive government with some quite worthwhile policy. I'm not planning another election post but rather to indicate that much of my thinking of late has been dominated by the election and its aftermath. That combined with the fact that I've been busy with a range of other things has meant I've been quiet here for a while.

One of the things I've been doing is copyediting contributions for a volume due out next year. I'm one of its three editors. This week we received one more of the contributions (only two more left to come), an essay on Jonah from the perspective of First Peoples and minority biblical criticism. I won't say any more about the essay itself - you'll have to wait until the volume is published next year.

But the essay provided an opportunity to reflect some more on Jonah and and some quite disturbing aspects of this story. For those who might not be familiar with it, Jonah is the prophet sent by YHWH to preach repentance to Nineveh, the capital of Assyria. He refuses and flees to escape his prophetic commission, boarding a ship going to Tarshish i.e. roughly the opposite direction to Niniveh. He doesn't get far because YHWH calls up a fierce storm. The sailors try their best to outlast the storm but eventually cast Jonah overboard to appease the deity. Jonah is then promptly swallowed by a big fish. He is trapped inside the fish three days and three nights before being disgorged on land. He then goes to Nineveh and preaches to them warning that they will be destroyed unless they repent. Jonah's preaching is astonishingly successful. All the Ninevites repent and Jonah's mission is a success. Jonah however is angry and despondent about his success and wishes for death. He complains to YHWH saying that this is the reason he fled and tried to refuse his commission. The book ends with a sulky and bitter Jonah wanting to die and being rebuked by YHWH for his bitterness.

Jonah is a most reluctant prophet and his reluctance and his subsequent bitterness at the success of his preaching has generated considerable puzzlement for many generations of biblical readers and interpreters. Why does he go such extraordinary lengths to avoid his divine commission and why is he so bitter at his success? A range of answers have been given which I will examine but first I'll give Jonah some context.

According to 2 Kings 14.25, Jonah son of Amittai came from the the village of Gath-Hepher in the north of Israel (not far from Nazareth). He correctly prophecies that the king of Israel, Jeroboam II (c. 786-746 BCE), will recover some territories lost to foreign invaders. Of course, Jonah is also the main character in the book that bears his name and which recounts his hapless sea flight and adventure with the fish and successful preaching in Nineveh. The book of Jonah is one of what's known as the 12 Minor Prophets, the 12 short books from Hosea to Malachi. While Christians have regarded them as 12 separate books, in Judaism they comprise one scroll known as The Twelve. For Jews the book of Jonah, is a sub-section of the larger book of the Twelve Minor Prophets. Jonah is the fifth of the Twelve in the Hebrew version following Hosea, Joel, Amos and Obadiah and immediately preceding Micah which is then followed by Nahum and the rest (in the Greek Septuagint Jonah is the 6th of the 12 and follows Hosea, Amos, Micah, Joel and Obadiah to immediately precede Nahum).

The Hebrew ordering will be significant when it comes to one explanation of Jonah's behaviour but first I want to look at a couple of others. Jonah's time in the belly of the fish, has from the gospels onwards been seen as prefiguring of Jesus' time in the tomb and so Jonah has long served as a type of Christ and even, by his mission to Gentile Nineveh, a foreshadowing of the Christian mission to the Gentiles as well as the Jews. There is a nastier Christian variant to this pattern, pioneered by Augustine but only picked up by Luther and then developed into a full anti-Jewish reading in the Enlightenment. Augustine's move, and Luther's following him, was to contrast the book with the prophet. Thus the book represents a universalist tendency in ancient Judaism that will be fulfilled in Christianity. Jonah the prophet however stands for insular, parochial and exclusivist Judaism and his bizarrre behaviour is the book's way of attacking and even mocking such Jewish exclusivism. Nineveh's repentance signifies the deity's shifting favor to the Gentiles and away from hidebound and insular Judaism.

In Islam, Jonah's repentance and not Nineveh's is understood is central to the story. Jonah is known as Yunus and Sura 10 of the Qur'an is named for him. Human repentance and the corresponding divine grace and mercy are the key messages for Islamic understanding.

Jewish readings have tended to highlight the problem of the successful prophet. According to Pirke de Rabbi Eliezer, Jonah had already been sent to preach doom to Jerusalem. The people heard his message and heeded, repenting and averting disaster. Paradoxically Jonah's success counts against him; he becomes the lying prophet. Preaching doom to Jerusalem generates Jerusalem's repentance meaning no doom. Jonah knows the same will happen in Nineveh so once again he will preach a doom that doesn't happen thus reinforcing his reputation as a failed prophet. By other accounts, it's not so much concern for his own reputation that so upsets Jonah but YHWH's reputation. Jonah delivers YHWH's message of doom, a doom that doesn't fall due to the people's repentance.

But there is yet another and even more disturbing possibility that derives from Jonah's placement in the Hebrew ordering of the Twelve (and his chronological location in 2 Kings). Jonah is a prophet and he knows that Nineveh/Assyria will ultimately destroy Israel, the kingdom and people to which Jonah belongs. In the biblical account not only is Israel destroyed by the Assyrians but its inhabitants are deported en masse never to return. The book of Micah which follows Jonah in the Hebrew ordering represents that catastrophe. It's from that image was derived the notion of the 10 lost tribes of Israel. From an historical point of view, while the Assyrians destroyed the kingdom of Israel, only about a third of the population were probably deported - there are no lost tribes, their descendants live on in the Samaritans and Palestinians. But Israel, the northern kingdom, would never more be seen again. The southern kingdom, Judah, was ravaged by and barely survived the Assyrians. It would eventually be destroyed by Babylon. At the time Jonah was likely written both Judah and Israel were provinces of the Persian empire (or perhaps even provinces of the post-Alexandrian empires). Unbeknown to the book's author, Judah would again become an independent kingdom under the Hasmoneans in the second century BCE and be a client Roman kingdom under Herod before finally being destroyed in the wars with Rome in the 1st and 2nd centuries CE. But not so the north; while its people were never lost, there would never again be an independent state located in the old Israelite heartland of Samaria.

Seen in that light Jonah's behaviour makes tragic sense. He is a prophet and he knows what Nineveh means for his people. If he preaches doom to Nineveh they will heed his message and be spared and thus enabled to go on and destroy Jonah's land and people. No wonder Jonah tries to run away, to even seek death in the depths of the ocean. There is an even more disturbing prospect to the story too. When Jonah preaches doom to Nineveh, all the Ninevites, from the highest to the lowest respond and repent most extravagantly. It could be argued that by their repentance they make themselves worthy to be YHWH's agents of destruction against Israel. By repenting they are now consecrated to YHWH's service for vengeance and punishment.

No wonder when last we see him, Jonah is bitter and wishing for death. He has aided and abetted the destruction of his own people.

Thursday, August 19, 2010

So this election I'm voting Greens 1, Labor 2, and I'm putting the COALition last

Only two more sleeps until the federal election and I'll be glad when it's done; it's been a most dispiriting and depressing campaign. If Australia used an electoral system like the US or the UK, I would have no hesitation in saying vote Labor. Indeed on any comparison between Labor and the Liberal/National COALition, Labor deserves to win. On Health, for example, Labor has a plan involving all but one of the States (and the recalcitrant WA will come on board in time) to revamp the health system. It doesn't address mental health or dental health but it's a start. And Julia Gillard has released a small scale mental health policy focussed on suicide prevention. Tony Abbott has released a large scale mental health policy but it's being funded by cuts to Labor's other health initiaitives including axing the new Superclinics. The COALition want to put funding into existing private GP clinics instead. However as Jennifer Doggett points out

Overall, this system has provided convenient and accessible care to many Australians much of the time. It is well designed to cope with acute and episodic care for people living in the cities who don’t have complex health or social problems.

However, there are large groups of Australians for whom this system is not working.

For example, rural, regional and remote communities frequently experience shortages of doctors as most GPs prefer to work in cities.


She also observes that people with chronic and complex conditions likewise aren't serviced well by private GPs.

Abbott is also planning further cuts to the Pharmaceutial Benefits Scheme and the privatisation of Medibank Private to boot. Furthermore the COALition's past record on health under Howard does not give me any confidence that an Abbott gov't has any idea of what to do on health except to outsource and privatise and maximise doctors' incomes.

Housing and homelessness is another area Labor has really made a difference in office. Tanya Plibersek, the relevant minister, has by all accounts done a superb job here. The COALition in office really ran down Australia's public housing stock and Abbott himself can only misquote Jesus to put the blame on the homeless themselves for their homelessness and explain away the need for any gov't action to address the issue. I should also point out that in office Labor did mitigate some of the worst aspects of Howard's brutopia, his use of welfare as a weapon of class war against the poor and vulnerable. Abbott for what I can see promises more of the same.

The National Broadband Network. This project alone is reason enough for Labor to be returned. It's a crucial piece of infrastructure that brings Australia into the 21st century. Tony Abbott proposes to axe it and proposes a half baked wireless scheme that shows he's still looking back to the past. But it highlights the whole problem with the COALition's approach to infrastructure, which as Grog's Gamut points out is a matter of 'Can't someone else do it?' The Libs/Nats are fundamentally lazy and prefer it if someone else does the heavy lifting.

Which brings me to the stimulus. If you listen to Abbott, Hockey and co Labor's stimulus package was a disaster for the country and they have done nothing but carp and whinge and lie about very aspect of the stimulus. And they keep going on and on about debt. The fact is that there was a global financial crisis and most of the industrialised world is still in a pretty bad way. Australia stands out for its success story. Mining didn't save us from recession when it came to the crunch; it was Labor's stimulus instead. As well as saving jobs, the stimulus package also provided valuable infrastructure (there's that word again) in schools and elsewhere. And given the global financial system is still shaky, the way that Abbott and Co harp and whinge and lie about the stimulus package does not give me much confidence in their ability to effectively handle another global financial crisis if things got rocky again, which they could given the state of the US.

Climate change. Tony Abbott is only Opposition Leader because the climate sceptics in the Liberal Party rebelled against the deal stitched between Labor and Malcolm Turnbull to implement an emissions trading scheme. Granted it was not the world's best scheme and gave out heaps of handouts to polluters, but even this was too much for the climate sceptics in the COALition who appear to be the majority and, if we can believe him, includes Tony Abbott himself. They certainly include Andrew Robb, touted as the Liberal smart man, and who played a key part in the overthrow of Turnbull and failure of the ETS. Lets face it any party that doesn't accept the facts of climate change is just not fit to govern.

Asylum seekers. Labor did get rid of the worst aspects of the Howard govt's treatment of asylum seekers, including ending the so-called Pacific Solution. Not only does Abbott promise to bring it back but the COALition jumped at every opportunity to lie and whip up xenophobic hysteria about asylum seekers coming here on boats. And it did so, playing to the most negative and mean spirited aspects of the collective pysche purely for political gain. These people are cruel but their cruelty is completely calculated. You just have to look at Phillip Ruddock who sold his soul for the perqs of office and literally died as a human being. He's still in Parliament, a moral husk, a zombie, cadaverous now. This sort of stuff is poison, spiritual poison and I say people who want to promote and drink that sort of Kool Aid are not fit for government.

Mention of Ruddock also highlights the degree of talent in the Opposition or should I say lack of talent. When I look at their front bench, the vacuous Julie Bishop, the preposterous Bronwyn Bishop, the ludicrous Christopher Pyne, the ridiculous Barnaby Joyce, the thoroughly toxic Kevin Andrews, the lazy Jo Hockey, the ruthless Andrew Robb, I mean really could anyone put government in their hands? And I could go one with Peter Dutton, Warren Truss, the totally venomous Sophie Mirabella. Is it any wonder that Malcolm Fraser, apart from Howard the only other living Liberal Prime Minister, left the party earlier this year because of its direction?

Labor on the other hand does have talented people and caring people, too, many of them. I've already mentioned Tanya Plibesek.

Now as I said, if we had a US or UK style electoral system, I would have no hesitation in voting Labor. But I would have to hold my nose too. Unfortunately Labor has decided that to win office it needs to play down or even forget its record and instead follow Tony Abbott in the race to the bottom. It's done so on asylum seekers and it has behaved disgracefully on climate change and ETS. Julia Gillard's policy of holding a citizens assembly to reach a consensus on the facts of climate change is a disgrace, especially as both sides went to the polls in 2007 with policies to establish an ETS. Both sides. The COALition have dumped theirs completely and Labor doesn't want to do anything without a consensus, at least for now. The irony is the majority of Australian want an ETS. In part Labor has been cowed by the media. And that's the other factor in this mess. The Australian media have in the main behaved disgracefully. Certainly over the last 8 months I don't think I've seen anything so bad since the days of the Whitlam gov't in the 70s when the newspapers turned a full blitzkrieg on Labor with the intent, especially in the Murdoch camp, to bring it down. That's happened this time too. Constant attack and lies, even giving major space to the most bizarre climate change sceptics.

And then there is Labor's proposed internet filter. I don't know why they are so doggedly pursuing it. Perhaps originally it might have been to win support off the Family First senator and serial fool, Steve Fielding. But he'll be gone after this election well when his term expires middle of next year. Let the filter go with him!

Luckily Australia has two electoral systems federally. In the lower House, we have a preferentially determined electorate system. I get to number the candidates standing or my electorate in order of preference and the candidate who gets the majority of preferential votes wins the seat. In the Senate we have a preferential list system, a little like some European systems I think. There are 6 Senate positions for Qld (and in each of the other states too). The Senate voting system especially favors minor parties getting up.

Once upon a time the Australian Democrats held the balance of power in the Senate which meant that the government of the day had to negotiate with them to get legislation through if it didn't have Opposition support. This process actually worked a lot of the time. The Democrats were centre left which also helped for a range of progressive concerns. There was a tie when it seemed that every second gay boy was a member of the Democrats.

The Democrats self-destructed badly in the Howard years but now we have The Greens. They're fairly progressive and as the name indicates are strong on environmental issues and policy. They are opposed to the demonising of asylum seekers, they are opposed to the internet filter and they strongly support action on climate change including establishing an ETS. They're in the Senate already and this time around they will probably get a senator elected from Qld. The COALition have 4 senators up for re-election, which would be a miracle, and Labor 2. So I'll be giving my first preference to the Greens and then, voting below the line, to Labor and down to the Liberal National party (luckily in Qld they amalgamated) last. That way I can send a a message to Labor too that I do not approve of the shift to the Right they've taken and ensure a progressive presence in the Senate that's not subject to ALP discipline.

In the lower House, I'm in the Labor held seat of Brisbane. Changing demographics mean that the incumbent. Arch Bevis, has a tough fight on his hand. This year the Greens are running Andrew Bartlett, former Democrat senator for Qld, as their candidate. I have a bit of time for Andrew and so I'm giving him my first preference with Labor's Arch at number 2. If Arch has to rely on Green preferences to get back, all the better. It once again sends a message to the ALP powers that be that the direction they've been taking the party is the wrong one and they need to change course.

I think it was Paul Keating who said, change the government and you change the country, and it's quite true. Whitlam changed this country immeasurably for the better, Hawke and Keating brought in major changes some good, some not so. Howard took this country down some very disturbing paths and we're still trying to rid ourselves of the most noxious aspects of the Howard years. Tony Abbott was groomed by Howard. He heads a group of people outstanding for their shortsightedness, complacency, nastiness and laziness. Furthermore, Abbott is promising a renewed class war on the poor and vulnerable (including further cuts in higher education on programs that support poorer students) plus complete refusal to acknowledge the reality of climate change. In other words, he will extend class war to the biosphere and to future generations too. On all those accounts he and his crowd do not deserve government at all.

On the other hand while Labor does deserve govt simply on its handling of the global financial crisis it also needs a serious kick up the backside. For that reason I will be voting Greens 1, Labor 2, and I will be doing my best to contribute to an Opposition loss by putting them last.

UPDATE Grog's Gamut on the election campaign and polling on day 34 of the campaign

And the 'psychic' croc calls it for Julia

FURTHER UPDATE 10 Reasons Not to Vote for Tony Abbott


Sunday, August 15, 2010

Celebrating the Dormition/Assumption of Mary the Godbearer/Theotokos

Today, August 15, is one of the big feasts of the Catholic world. In the Latin communion it is known as the Feast of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary. In the Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox and Eastern Catholic communions it is known as the Dormition or falling asleep of the Theotokos or Godbearer (but those who still use the Julian calendar won't celebrate it until Gregorian August 28). In the Anglican communion, it's the Feast of the Falling Asleep of the Blessed Virgin Mary. As well as marking the death of the Virgin Mary the day also celebrates her Assumption, being taken up, resurrected, body and soul into the heavenly realm. The Roman communion teaches that she was resurrected on the day of her death but the Orthodox communions teach that she was resurrected three days after her death. In 1950, Pope Pius XII declared the Assumption a necessary item of belief for the Roman communion, a declaration welcomed by Carl Jung (curiously, this Papal declaration is the only instance of a dogma declared invoking Papal Infallibility since it was affirmed in 1870 at Vatican I). Many Anglicans and some Lutherans too believe that Mary was resurrected after her death. Some Catholics, mostly in the Roman communion believe that Mary didn't die at all but was translated alive into the heavenly realm, something like Enoch in Genesis and the Enoch literature and also Elijah (but without the chariot). This is an old idea, the first clear instance of which is found in the 4th century when Epiphanius of Salamis said that no one knew whether Mary had died or not. According to the Wikipedia entry on the Assumption, the day is a public holiday in many countries including Andorra, Austria, Belgium, Bosnia, Burundi, Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chile, Republic of Congo, Cote d'Ivoire, Croatia, Colombia, Cyprus, East Timor, France, Gabon, Greece, Republic of Guinea, Haiti, Italy, Lebanon, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Republic of Macedonia, Madagascar, Malta, Mauritius, Monaco, Paraguay, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Rwanda, Senegal, Seychelles, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland, Tahiti, Togo and Vanuatu (I must admit I kind of like the idea of having a public holiday to celebrate an obscure peasant woman from 1st century Roman Palestine). As it falls on a Sunday this year I hope those countries follow the Australian practice of observing a compensatory holiday on the Monday. In Ethiopia, the day is also marked by a women's festival called Ashenda. I can't find out much more about Ashenda but Ethiopian Christianity is itself some 1600 years old so perhaps it derives from the pre-Christian past or maybe it is an Ethiopian Christian invention.

Mary, of course might be an obscure peasant woman from 1st century Palestine but for Catholic Christianity her very obscurity is key to her status. She is the model of what it means to be Christian who, in the words of the medieval German mystic and theologian, Meister Eckhart, are called to give birth to God in their lives. It's important to recall too that in Catholic teaching, both East and West, Mary freely works with God in a synergy. Hers is not a mere obedience or submission but a free consent, willing trust and active collaboration that are fundamental to her role. Through her Assumption, Mary models the entire Christian hope of deification, a deification that will extend to the entire cosmos. Mary instantiates the ancient deification principle that the glory of God is humanity fully alive. While she might seem like a goddess and no doubt has drawn on a variety of ancient goddesses as Christianity spread, she is greater than any goddess, precisely because she is human and indeed she humanises those old goddesses, mother goddesses, virgin goddesses, wisdom goddesses. Thus she demonstrates that Christianity is a form of applied Kabbalah, drawing out, releasing and lifting up (humanising) the sparks of the divine throughout creation, including within the deities and powers of the old religions.

It's these 'pagan' associations that lead many, particularly Protestants, to dismiss Mary and her cult. However, I would argue that to be true to its Jewish origins Christianity can only ever be both sacramental and Marian, Catholic. When Jesus stepped into that 1st century messianic gestalt, it would automatically incorporate his mother. I have written before on miraculous motherhood and ancient Judaism. But I also want to point you to an excellent essay by Margaret Barker, "Images of Mary in the Litany of Loreto" (pdf). Here's a sample to whet your appetite:

The world of the temple and the teaching of its priests was a sophisticated theology that now has to be reconstructed from many ancient texts, but it is clear that this is where Christianity has its roots. The Christians saw in Jesus the fulfilment of temple rites, which foreshadowed his work of salvation (Heb. 9.11–14),10 and they described him as Melchisedech, the high priest of the ancient royal house who was, in a way we no longer fully understand, the presence of the Lord on earth (Heb. 7.11–22). It was therefore to be expected that Mary was described as Wisdom, the Queen of Heaven, the Mother of the Lord on earth. The titles in the Litany of Loreto, and in many other praises of Mary, were drawn from the Wisdom tradition...

In this article I shall show that Wisdom was a fundamental figure in the ancient faith of Jerusalem, that the Church claimed Wisdom’s titles for Mary from the very beginning, and that by the time the Litany of Loreto was composed, the meaning of some of these titles was fading and their significance already lost. The titles in the Litany seem to be a summary of a much older tradition.

I don't agree with all of Barker's historical reconstructions of ancient Israelite Temple religion but I think her overall picture fits quite well with an understanding of ancient Judaism evolving out of an older Palestinian/Canaanite 'pagan' milieu, an evolution that was still happening even in Jesus' and Mary's own time. If Christianity could subsequently connect with 'pagan' traditions within and without the Roman Empire, it was precisely through its Jewish background/origins and not in spite of it.

In her essay, Barker refers to two Christian prayers or hymns, the Litany of Loreto and the Akathist Hymn to the Mother of God. For those unfamiliar with them, I've embedded links to the texts. The Akathist Hymn probably dates back to the 6th century and is important in the liturgy of Eastern Christianity. Akathist means not sitting and is a genre of hymnody in the East. One recurring Marian title in the Akathist Hymn to the Mother of God that I really like is Unwedded Bride.

Here is an excerpt from the hymn in English with visuals of some marvelous icons:



And here is another beautiful version in Arabic, again with some stunning icons:




And a Russian version, note the fabulous image of Mary on the bishop's vestments at the start:



And here's some more Marian music to celebrate the Dormition/Assumption, mostly from the East as a reminder that Western Christianity is not and never has been all there is to Christianity.

Here is a hymn specifically for the Dormition:




In giving birth thou didst preserve thy virginity; /
in thy dormition thou didst not forsake the world, O Theotokos. /
Thou wast translated unto life, / since thou art the Mother of Life; //
and by thine intercessions dost thou deliver our souls from death.

Kontakion, Tone 2:
The grave and death could not hold the Theotokos, /
who is sleepless in her intercessions and an unfailing hope in her mediations. /
For as the Mother of Life she was translated unto life //
by Him Who dwelt in her ever-virgin womb.

Exapostilarion:
O ye Apostles from afar, being now gathered together
here in the garden of Gethsemane, give burial to my body;
and Thou, my Son and my God, receive Thou my spirit.



And here is an Arabic hymn to Mary from Egypt which features a stunning image of Mary from the doe of the Coptic church in Zeitoun Cairo where in 1968-70 millions of Christians and Muslims saw a series of Marian apparitions:



(To find out more about the apparitions you can go here)

And here is another Egyptian hymn, Shere Ne Maria



I found this English text for it on a Coptic site

Shere Ne Maria Holy Virgin Mary
Shere Ne Maria Who art all Holy
Shere Ne Maria Due to you the glory
Shere Ne Maria Ethmav Empi Mayromi
Shere Ne Maria Sweet mother of light
Shere Ne Maria Who art always bright
Shere Ne Maria Standing on his right
Shere Ne Maria Asking day and night
Shere Ne Maria Hail full of grace
Shere Ne Maria Show thy glorious face
Shere Ne Maria Most kind in any case
Shere Ne Maria Intercede for thine poor race
Shere Ne Maria Through thy intercession
Shere Ne Maria Hear my petition
Shere Ne Maria And save from perdition
Shere Ne Maria Any pure Christian

As I said before, in Ethiopia the Assumption is the occasion for a women's festival called Ashenda. Here's a clip with music and dance for Ashenda:



And moving to the West, here is a beautiful setting of the Angelus with Ave Maria (Hail Mary), one of the great Marian prayers of the West, by the 20th century composer Franz Biebl:



And I thought I'd finish with a clip of Nina Hagen singing Ave Maria live. Love her work!






And if you want to read some ancient Christian texts about the Dormition you will find a collection at Stephen Shoemaker's site here.



Saturday, August 14, 2010

About Another Jewish Temple in Ancient Egypt

I've written before touching on the ancient Jewish community at Elephantine in southern Egypt and their Temple. Not only did this Temple community feel connected to both the Temples in Jerusalem and Samaria but it also seems to have practiced a form of polytheistic Judaism. At the very least Yahweh was worshipped with a consort. The Elephantine Temple didn't survive the Persian period and was no longer functioning when Alexander the Great arrived on the scene. However, Hellenistic Egypt under the Ptolemies saw the establishment of yet another Jewish Temple in the 2nd century BCE, this time at the city of Leontopolis in the Nile delta region of northern Egypt.

The Ptolemies seem to have been a very important, even beneficial, factor for ancient Judaism. Not only did Ptolemaic Egypt contain large communities of what would later be called Jews and Samaritans, some of whom like their antecedents at Elephantine appear to have enlisted for military service, but for more than a century Palestine/Coele-Syria was itself a province of the Ptolemaic kingdom. The Ptolemies do not appear to have interfered in the running of either of the Palestinian Temples at Mt Gerizim and Jerusalem. Indeed, according to the 2nd century BCE Letter of Aristeas it was the Ptolemy II Philadelphus (283-46BCE) who commissioned a Greek translation of the Torah that would become the basis for the Greek Bible, the Septuagint, later to become the Christian Old Testament. (The Letter of Aristeas also provides a detailed description of Jerusalem and its Temple in the 3rd/2nd centuries BCE).

However this happy state of affairs came to an end at the start of the 2nd century BCE when Antiochus III (ruled 223-187 BCE) of the Seleucid Empire to the north seized control of Palestine from the Ptolemaic state. In particular, in 175 BCE Antiochus IV Epiphanes came to the throne and began interfering in the operations of the Jerusalem Temple. In 171 BCE, the High Priest, Onias III, was murdered at Antioch, the Seleucid capital (2 Maccabees 4.33). While the ancient accounts are inconsistent it appears a son of Onias fled to Egypt seeking refuge at the Ptolemaic court. This son, also called Onias, then sought permission from Ptolemy VI to establish a Jewish sanctuary in Egypt. Ptolemy still hoped to regain Palestine and granted Onias' request. The Temple was built at Leontopolis in the central delta region. It appears too that the Temple was endowed as well by Ptolemy.

The most detailed descriptions of the Temple are found in the works of Josephus in both his Antiquities and Jewish War. The Jewish Encyclopedia summarises these descriptions thus

(The Temple) was built on the site of a ruined temple of Bubastis, in imitation of the temple at Jerusalem, though smaller and less elaborate (Ant.xiii. 3, § 3). The "fortress" (ὀχύρωμα) of the temple of Bubastis may be explained by the statement, which seems credible, that Onias built a fortress (θρωύριον) around the temple in order to protect the surrounding territory, which now received the designation "Oneion" ("B. J." vii. 10, § 3).

The Onias temple was not exactly similar to the Temple at Jerusalem, being more in the form of a high tower; and as regards the interior arrangement, it had not a candelabrum, but a hanging lamp. The building had a court (τέμενος) which was surrounded by a brick wall with stone gates. The king endowed the temple with large revenues (ib.)


In fact, because of the Temple the area became known as the Land of Onias.

If the Ptolemies thought that establishing a Jewish Temple in Egypt would return Palestine to their control, they would be disappointed. Antiochus' interference in and eventual desecration of the Jerusalem Temple provoked the Jews of Judea to revolt under the Maccabees. The revolt was successful and an independent state of Judea was established under the Hasmonean High Priests. Eventually they would take control of all of Palestine and rule it as priest-kings until the Romans came in the mid-1st century BCE.

The Temple at Leontopolis outlasted the Ptolemies, the Seleucids and the Hasmoneans. All up it seems to have lasted for about 243 years being closed by the Romans around 73 CE after the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple in 70 CE during the First Jewish War. The Romans were apparently afraid that a continuing Jewish Temple might keep the fires of rebellion burning. Ironically the Second Jewish War against Rome, in 115-17 CE, began in Cyrene, modern day eastern Libya, but in the ancient world part of the Ptolemaic state, and then spread to Egypt itself and then Cyprus, which had also been part of the Ptolemaic Empire and also had a large Jewish population, before subsequently spreading to Judea and then to the Jewish communities of Mesopotamia, only recently conquered by Rome. Rome suppressed this revolt with disastrous consequences for the Jews of Egypt, Cyrene and Cyprus in particular. But I wonder if the Temple at Leontopolis had been allowed to continue whether the revolt would still have taken place. There's no record of the Temple ever being associated with seditious activity, unlike Jerusalem. At the same time it was regarded as a legitimate sanctuary and not a rival or threat to Jerusalem and presumably had a sacral authority, an authority that would be enhanced by its status as the sole Temple after 70.

I also wonder about a pretty basic question, who paid for the Temple over the 243 years of its existence. It appears that Ptolemy VI endowed the Temple when it was established. But at same time temples can be expensive operations to run. First off you have the staff to support. All reports indicate that Leontopolis had both priests and Levites and sustained the full cycle of ritual and sacrifice. The Temple had to be maintained as well as its vessels and vestments and other accouterments. And then there were the needs of the cult itself - animals for sacrifice, incense, grain, wine, plus the fuel for burning the offerings. Presumably there was a Temple Library as well and perhaps even some sort of facility for the production of texts. Priests, Levites, scribes and other Temple personnel would also have to have been trained as well. Either Ptolemy VI gave a quite substantial endowment or perhaps his successors topped it up with their own endowments as well. After all the Temple at Jerusalem relied on a Temple tax levied on Jews around the Empire to help finance it and it was a major pilgrimage site too, always good for revenue. But Leontopolis does not seem to have been a major pilgrim centre (although that may have changed if it had been allowed to continue after 73). If subsequent Ptolemaic rulers did top up the resources of the Leontopolis Temple what happened when Ptolemaic rule came to an end and was replaced by Roman rule in 30 BCE? Did the Roman administration provide any resources to maintain the Temple for the last century of its life too? And as I come to the end of this post I still wonder whether there would have been a Second Jewish War, a war fought almost entirely within the old Ptolemaic domain, if the Leontopolis Temple had not been closed. What would Judaism and even Christianity have been like if the Temple had been able to continue? Intriguing what ifs.

One other observation I have to make is that it seems there never was a time when the Temple in Jerusalem was the sole Temple of Jewish or Israelite or Yahweh religion even though it would appear that it often tried to present itself as such.

The site of ancient Leontopolis is currently known as Tell el Yahudiyeh and was excavated by Flinders Petrie in 1905/06.

There's a post on the Leontopolis Temple over at PhDiva with a link to a review of an Italian study of the Temple and more details on the Temple at the Jewish Encyclopedia site.

There's also a good overview of the history of the Jews in Egypt from the 7th century BCE to the present day here at Wikipedia.

Tuesday, July 20, 2010

Another What If... Using "Scripture" to "Teach" "Ethics"... and a whole lot more

I saw an interesting item a week or so ago in the Fairfax press; an opinion piece by David Hill titled "Churches don't have monopoly on the good life" and tagged 'Ethics Courses as Alternative to Scripture Classes in Schools'. It seems there's been an experiment in the NSW education system, a trial providing weekly ethics courses for school students in the government education system who don't attend the weekly religious instruction classes provided by the churches. These RI classes are called scripture classes.

It seems that the trial was a success and the participating students really enjoyed the ethics classes. It went down so well that the churches, especially the Roman Catholic and Anglican denominations want the ethics classes to made available to all and not as an alternative to their scripture classes. In fact there seems to be a fear that the ethics classes might prove so popular that they even draw students away from the scripture classes so the churches have mounted a campaign called, very tellingly, Save Our Scripture.

Now I have no idea how these so-called scripture classes are run or what they're like. It's been a long time since my school days and I'd like to think things have changed a bit since then. What's more I was taught in the Catholic system, in my childhood by the Josephite nuns at the local convent school. Back in those days the entire education system, government and non-government, seemed designed to bore students so much that they would never get interested in anything to do with thinking and reflection. Religion was much the same. We had our penny catechism which we learnt off by heart - I've pretty much forgotten all of it now. We also had something called a Bible history which was an illustrated collection of stories from Old and New Testaments. It wasn't the actual text, however, just a retold version in the long tradition of children's bible story anthologies. As we got older the penny catechism was replaced by a more complex hard cover catechism and the bible history by a copy of Knox's Four Gospels translated from the Latin Vulgate. But we really didn't read that much scripture and what we read was embedded in a tight doctrinal matrix underpinned by the catechisms.

I'd assume that scripture classes wouldn't operate like that any more, at least for Catholics, and presumably Uniting Church and Anglicans. But then the Sydney Archdiocese is very conservative and then there are all those very conservative Protestant denominations (presumably the Orthodox and Jews and Muslims and other religions have their own 'scripture' classes too). So I wondered just how and how much scripture might actually be taught in these so-called 'scripture' classes; were they actually doing a very good job of turning the students off scripture altogether?

Maybe because I was Catholic and we Catholics didn't read Bibles in those days, and coming to biblical studies later in life, I have a much greater appreciation of these anthologies of texts called imperially The Bible and I realise just how important these stories, these collections of narrative and poetry and polemic, actually are, not least in cultural terms. And so I began entertaining another what if...

What if 'scripture' was used in schools as a basis to teach ethics and a range of other stuff too. I'm not talking about religious instruction, mind. Far from it. No, what I imagine is something like a regular reading group where students from the start of their schooldays would read the text in an atmosphere where they would be encouraged, according to what I understand (from a rabbi I used to know) is the best of Jewish tradition, that is to always ask why, what is going on here whenever they see something odd, puzzling, shocking or even boring in the text. Because lets face it, there's some pretty wild and puzzling and quite outrageous stories in these scriptures (and some boring bits too) and I think stories like these are the best for ethical reflection not to mention stretching the imagination.

English is the main language of Australia and so I would make the King James Bible, the text for this enterprise. That way students can be introduced to the rich cadences of the language, but which, being some four centuries old, will contain words and usages that are alien. It would also have to be the King James with the so-called Apocrypha, so as to cross over most of the various biblical canons, not just the standard Protestant one. What I envisage is not a denominational exercise. Furthermore I would want the students to read a good English translation of the Qur'an alongside the Bible. That way they can learn how the biblical stories have been retold and live on in Islamic cultures, too, making the stories and characters central to the imaginative life of a plethora of cultures, Christian and Islamic as well as Jewish, over time and space.

My childhood was in the days before Vatican 2 and so I lived then in the world of the Latin Mass. While I don't necessarily miss it as such, I am grateful for spending my childhood in a religious culture with another language to English. As kids we weren't taught Latin but we were schooled in the Latin Mass; we learnt the Latin responses and we could see what they meant in the English translation in our missals. I think that, albeit limited, bi-lingual environment was enriching. Jews and Muslims read their scriptures in Hebrew or Arabic putting them in a similarly enriching bi-lingual environment (even for Arabs - the classical Arabic of the Qur'an is different to the modern Arabics spoken today). Studying the Bible can also create an enriching multi-lingual environment, not just because the King James uses an older form of English but because the stories were composed and transmitted in several different ancient languages. So when the students read Genesis 1.1 in the King James - In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth - they can also be introduced to the older Hebrew, Greek, Latin forms of the text

Bereshit bara elohim eth hashamayim w'eth ha-arets

En arche epoieisen ho theos ton ouranon kai tein gein
('ei' pronounced as in vein or neigh)

In principio creavit deus caelam et terram

They can also be introduced to the Arabic opening - In the name of God/Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful - of the Qur'an too

Bismillahi r-rahman r-rahim

Both the Hebrew scriptures and the Qur'an are sung or chanted texts and so in the first couple of years the students can both read in English and sing or chant in Hebrew and Arabic or at least listen to these texts sung and chanted (and chanted in Latin and Greek too). And so they become exposed to other languages, their linguistic repertoire is expanded. And there is indeed a whole rich world of music around these texts that they can be introduced to, as well as a world of art, film and literature. The biblical world on the internet is vast as is the Qur'an's internet world. Scripture classes can also become great vehicles to teach young people how to work the world of the internet.

As for ethics, well lets start with the Genesis creation stories. Read together with their versions in the Qur'an opens up the world of plurality already but if the school's students are multi-ethnic and multi-faith then it enables the opportunity to share stories from outside the biblical/quranic matrix, Hindu stories, Buddhist stories, Chinese and Japanese stories, and, most importantly in Australia, indigenous stories. If the school is more 'mono' in its faith and ethnic profile then there remain the stories from Greek and Roman and Egyptian and other related mythology too. I remember learning about the Greek myths in the local convent school; for the life of me I can't remember why we learned those stories but we did. What I'm getting at here is cultivating an ethics of listening and sharing and appreciating difference. The Jewish tradition of the midrashim can further reinforce how the biblical stories have been retold and reworked, added to, enhanced, to thus foster an ethics of creativity and, again, appreciation of plurality.

As the students get older then the ethical questions get more interesting, more challenging. In Genesis 1, the text repeats the refrain 'and God saw that it was good' as the great tone poem of creation unfolds. Can we say that the universe is good? What does it mean to say that? Is the universe bad? or indifferent? What then are the implications? There are other ethical questions in Genesis 1 too. How do humans relate to, engage with the rest of the earth? Is it just there for us to exploit any way we like? Related to that is the fact that the vision of human life in Genesis 1 is a vegetarian one - 'Behold, I have given you every herb bearing seed, which is upon the face of all the earth, and every tree, which is the fruit of a tree yielding seed; to you it shall be for meat' (1.29). So what are the ethics of our treatment of animals? The Genesis text already provides a means for opening up discussion of some pretty weighty ethical issues. And then there is also 'God created humankind in his image, in the image of God he created them; male and female he created them' and 'Be fruitful, and multiply' - how do we go about the ethics of gender and sexuality. And that's just in the first chapter!

These themes get reprised again in the Eden stories along with another biggie, truth and falsehood. Who's telling the truth and who's lying in these stories? God? the serpent? Eve? Adam? And we're still only three chapters in. The rest of the biblical world is bursting with stories that raise a suite of further ethical issues. Power is a big one, not just with David and Solomon and the kings, there's also Joshua and Ezra and then the whole deployment of power in the Gospel narratives. David Hill gives as reasons why parents don't want their children to attend scripture classes 'Others complain that little children should not be traumatised by stories of the crucifixion or the threat of spending eternity ''burning in hell''.' The crucifixion is ugly, terrible, vile, that's the whole point. The story in its various forms raises a suite of ethical issues about power, its deployment, how to respond to it. As a child I was horrified by Herod's massacre of the infants of Bethlehem. Power continues to be used every day to destroy people in brutal ways - and these stories remind us of that fact. And, as with the case of the Hebrew midwives in Exodus, they remind us that people can resist such power too. As for hell, well that's an interesting ethical conundrum in itself, one which I've discussed elsewhere on this blog. While there's little or no hell in the Old Testament and not that much in the New either, an allied question is the ethics of divinity in the scriptures. God is a character in these stories and therefore should not be exempt from criticism or ethical evaluation. Does God's behavior through the Flood, at Sodom and Gomorrah, does such behavior give warrant for genocide? And what about holy war and the ban, the massacre of Canaanite and Amalekite?

And then there is the whole tangled web of gender and sexuality. The love lives (or more appropriately sex lives) of Abraham and Jacob and Samson and David and Solomon, and the poetics of rape and abuse in the prophets, just to name some. What can be made of Jephthah's daughter or the concubine at Gibeah? This is not a Brady Bunch world of sugar and schmaltz (let alone Father Knows Best) but a bizarre and frightening and ethically problematic world, the perfect space to exercise and cultivate ethical reflection. And this world does not exist in a vacuum either. There is more than two thousand years of Jewish, Christian, Muslim and other ethical debate and reflection around these stories. Was Lot right to offer his daughters to the mob? Jewish tradition offers an unequivocal 'no' but Christians and Muslims, are not so clear cut. Augustine's discussion of whether Lot was right or wrong to do so is a text that should be studied and evaluated in developing an ethical framework. Was Augustine right or wrong in his conclusions? And was Augustine uncomfortable with them? I think Augustine was wrong but I also think he wasn't happy with the conclusion he had reached or, at least, understood it was problematic.

Now I'm not proposing that students in grade 1 read Augustine. He, along with other Christian theologians and mystics and heretics, Gnostics, rabbis and kabbalists, sheikhs and imams and sufis, philosophers and the odd few Marxists, Freudians, feminists and other ratbags would come later as the students got older. They would be progressively introduced to these people throughout their school lives, along with the novelists, poets, dramatists, artists, composers and film-makers via the Bible and the Qur'an (which would be read beside the biblical texts in every class on scripture). Through the study of scripture students would be put in conversation with a wide variety of people, thinkers/artists, not just within the English language tradition but from a broad spectrum of cultures around the world and from across the last two to three thousand years.

To highlight the global and pluralist dimensions of these scriptures I had considered banning the adherents of the religions based on them - Christians, Jews, Muslims, Bahais, Druze, modern-day Gnostics, (and where do the Sikhs fit? [1]) - from having any role in teaching them. I would also include all those vigorous atheists of the Dawkins and Hitchens variety who by so striving to discredit these texts, in their very rejection make themselves as uncritically captive to these texts and hidebound as any fundamentalist Baptist or Salafi. So the teachers would have to be indigenous Australians or members of other primal indigenous traditions, Hindus, Parsis/Zoroastrians, Buddhists, Daoists, Shintoists, Jains, Cao Dai, etc, (and where do the Sikhs fit? [1]). I must admit I rather like that idea (even if it precludes such as myself). But then I felt that perhaps Jews should be excepted in honour of the rabbi who stressed to me that you must never be reluctant to ask why when you read these texts. So I have changed my mind. Instead I think the classes should be taught by a team of at least two, of whom at least one must come from a religio-cultural tradition not shaped by this Middle Eastern scriptural/religious matrix. Thus the cross-cultural dialogic framework can be reinforced. The other guideline then that I would place on these teaching teams is that it is okay for the teachers to disagree, even strongly disagree on any reading or evaluation of the stories and characters. Such disagreement could even be encouraged, so long as it was respectful. Here I'm mindful of the old saw 'put two Jews together and you will have three opinions'. And I guess I can't help but think of the yeshiva practice where young Jews argue and debate scripture as they study it and where in these debates if one party exhausts an argument the other party will help them to resume it by working out a critique of their own opposing position.

Obviously such secular teaching of scripture in every year of school could not then be the preserve only of the government school system. No, such teaching of scripture would have to become an integral part of the entire schooling system, public and private, secular and faith-based, school based and distance and somehow as part of home-schooling operations too. Indeed it would provide an essential corrective in schools run by more fundamentalist faith communities, Christian and otherwise.

Of course I realise this is a utopian vision and given the timorous and blinkered petit bourgeois mindset that dominates the politics of this country, as evidenced by the current election, these utopian imaginings have as much chance of success as a snowflake's in Hell (the old-fashioned traditional variety of Hell anyway). But given the singular importance of these scriptures in world history and imagination, not to mention our own Anglo cultural-linguistic trajectory, I don't think they deserve anything less. What's more I don't think children, young people deserve anything less either. These are the stories of their ancestors, of our ancestors, even much moreso now that we are a multi-cultural, multi-faith, multi-lingual society. These stories bring contemporary young people into conversation with those ancestors across two to three thousand years. These stories reveal to them the imaginary framework of their culture/s and language/s. And these stories give them the opportunity to enrich, explore and expand both their imaginative horizon and their ethical framework. Thus, I would suggest, they may become more fully human, surely the prime goal of any meaningful education.

[1] Not to mention Mandaeans and Yezidis.

Sunday, July 18, 2010

What If? Not Jerusalem but Samaria is the birthplace of the Bible

In between the depressive moments and my community/other commitments I've been reflecting a bit on the history of biblical religion or more precisely on how biblical religion and the corpus of texts that generate it got going. As part of that reflecting I had a little 'what if' moment that I want to share here. What if Jerusalem and its Temple are not the site for the origins of the bible scriptures but somewhere else? Samaria, perhaps?

Before I spell it out I want to first off reprise the standard, dare one say 'traditional', understanding of how the texts we call biblical/Old Testament came to be. In the Bibles used by Christians and Jews, whatever else one can say, Jerusalem and its Temple are so very central. One could say the Old Testament collections are really arguing about who should be in control of Jerusalem and its Temple. These arguments occur again in the New Testament collections which go on to say that the days of Jerusalem are over and that the Christian community gathered together is the New Temple, a Temple of the Spirit to replace the Temple of Stone. But that Temple of Stone was in Jerusalem and the new Christian regime is signified by a New Jerusalem that comes down from heaven, a New Jerusalem with no need for a Temple of stone.

This scriptural centrality of Jerusalem is such that in the various hypotheses of the origins of these texts, it's always assumed that the biblical enterprise begins in Jerusalem. The classic example is the documentary hypothesis of the origins and composition of the Torah, the 5 books of Moses, at the heart of Tanakh and Old Testament. The first version of the Torah, the famous book of J, is composed and written by the mythical Yahwist in Jerusalem sometime around when David or Solomon were supposed to have reigned. Deuteronomy, the D or Deuteronomist component, is likewise believed to have been composed in Jerusalem, and 'traditionally' understood to be the scroll of the Law found in the Temple in Josiah's day, prompting him to undertake a major reform and centralisation of the cult in the last days before the Babylonian conquest. Post-Babylon the Torah collection is further revised and edited by priests in Jerusalem, the P or Priestly component. At some stage, however, following the Assyrian conquest of the northern kingdom of Israel/Samaria, refugees from the north brought their own traditions which were also incorporated into the growing Torah corpus, the E or Elohist component, at some stage before the days of Josiah. The north then is ancillary to the whole process which is understood as being located in Jerusalem. Biblical minimalists, too, locate the entire process of Torah composition in a Persian or Hellenistic period Jerusalem.

The curious thing, though, is that there is no clear reference Jerusalem or its holy mountain, Zion, anywhere in the Torah, with the possible exception of the story of Melchizedek of Salem in Genesis 14, to which I will return later. On the other hand, various northern sanctuaries and even the Samaritan holy mountain, Ha Gerizim, are both present and important sites in the Torah. Mt Gerizim and its twin or sister peak, Mt Ebal, appear in Deuteronomy itself (11.29, 27.12), a text generally understood as representing the platform or core agenda of the Jerusalem-only trajectory in the scriptures and presumably of a Jerusalem based party in the period of composition. In Deuteronomy and again in Joshua (8.33) Mt Gerizim is clearly a site of considerable significance for the Israelites, a place of meeting for cultic obligations laid down by Moses himself.

As for Melchizedek, while nowadays it's generally accepted that the Genesis story is a reference to Jerusalem, Samaritan tradition understands Salem to have been at Shechem at the foot of Mt Gerizim. Curiously both in early Christianity and early Judaism Salem is identified with Shechem and there are stories of Melchizedek as a king of the north and not of Jerusalem. In part, this identification of Salem and Shechem is made possible by the Hebrew of Genesis 33.18, 'and Jacob came safely to the city of Shechem', the word for 'safely' is salem. Consequently, the Latin, Greek and Syriac versions of the text say 'and Jacob came to Salem, the city of Shechem'. Samaritans identify Mt Gerizim with Mt Moriah the site where Abraham took Isaac for sacrifice; Jews of course identify it with Mt Zion. The Binding of Isaac is not historical, of course, but a myth deriving from ancient Temple theologies of sacrifice, so the location of any (central) temple will likewise be the location for the events of the myth (just as, for Muslims, Mecca is the site for Ibrahim's binding of Ismail, the same mythic pattern).

It used to be thought, following Josephus, that the Temple in Jerusalem was the first to be rebuilt, in the Persian period, with the Samaritans only building theirs on Mt Gerizim in the time of Alexander the Great. Archeology has given the lie to that. It would appear that the re/building of both Temples began at about the same time early in the Persian period. Likewise it would appear from the evidence of the ancient Jewish community at Elephantine in southern Egypt, that both Jerusalem and Samaria were recognised as authoritative centres for Jews (or would it be better to designate these communities as Yahweh worshippers?).

What's been most interesting for me in my reading is to discover that, geographically, the northern regions of Samaria are much richer country for farming and other activities, than the southern regions of Judah/Yehud. The imaginative centrality of Jerusalem obscures that fact. Judah began as a poor client kingdom of the much richer Israel/Samaria/House of Omri in the north. And it would seem that the Persian province of Yehud and its capital, Jerusalem, were likewise much poorer than the province of Samaria to the north. So to return to my what if, what if the origins of the biblical process lay in Samaria, and specifically, the Temple at Mt Gerizim, and not Jerusalem. What if the great stories of Eden, Noah, Abraham and Sarah and Hagar, Isaac and Rebecca, Jacob and Leah and Bilhah and Zilpah and Rachel, Joseph and his brothers and sister, Moses and Miriam and Aaron and Joshua, have their origins entirely in the north and not the south? What if the process of scripture/Torah composition began at Ha Gerizim but expanded into a bigger collaborative exercise incorporating the other sanctuaries of 'Israelite' religion. I have been thinking for a while that one of the factors important to the transformation of ancient Palestinian religion into Judaism(s), Samaritanism(s?), Christianity, Gnosticism, Islam, Bahai etc, was the critical question, what does a cult focused on a local king-priest (a Melchizedek) do when the local kings have gone, to be replaced by a distant imperial ruler of a world empire, in which once local cults have to face realities of globalisation and diaspora. In part this process, may well have been initiated by the colonisers, the imperial power itself (hence the generally positive image of the Persians in the Hebrew scriptures). But I think that the colonised took advantage of the process making it a sort of pas de deux, or even a pas de trois.

Somewhere along the way, there was a falling out between north and south. Perhaps the centralising logic of Deuteronomy, prompted a radical pre-emptive and defensive strike on the part of Jerusalem against its wealthier and more prestigious partner to the north. So Jerusalem set out to further develop the story but with Jerusalem at the heart of it all., not Ha Gerizim and, furthermore, to traduce all those sacred centres of the north that are so important to the sacred story of Genesis and even Joshua. That way Jerusalem successfully resisted control or worse from the north. Or maybe Jerusalem's motive was a far more mundane matter of cashing in on the pilgrim trade. Jerusalem and Yehud is poor and pilgrims bring money. We have plenty of examples in the ancient world of Temples with an international appeal. The Temple of Artemis in Ephesus was one such rich and internationally popular sanctuary. And certainly Jerusalem has known many periods of prosperity all thanks to its centrality in the religious imagination of countless numbers of people.

Sadly however, the Temple at Ha Gerizim lost out in the struggle and was finally destroyed at the behest of a Jerusalem high priest and de facto king, almost 130 years before Christ. But the people whose faith was centred on that northern sanctuary held on to their scriptures, the Torah of Moses. Their numbers would gradually dwindle in the face of Roman (the Samaritans joined with the Jews in the first Jewish War against Rome 66-72CE), Christian (the Samaritans rebelled unsuccessfully against the Eastern Roman/Byzantine Empire several times in the 5th and 6th centuries and were brutally suppressed by Emperor Justinian) and Muslim power (in the centuries of Muslim rule they suffered periodic forced conversions), to the tiny handful that they are. But the greatest tragedy is that they would never be credited with that immense achievement in human religious imagination (and to which they cling tenaciously) the Torah, the 5 Books of Moses.

Of course, it might not have been like that but what if...